top of page

If He Had Been with Me by Laura Nowlin - Review, Summary, Analysis & Facts

If He Had Been with Me by Laura Nowlin

Table of Contents

1. Book Details

Full Title:

If He Had Been with Me




Young Adult Contemporary Fiction

Number of Pages:

336 pages

Author - Who Wrote?

Laura Nowlin

Publication Date:

April 1, 2013

Country & Original Language:

United States; English


The story is set in a high school environment, exploring the lives of the characters within the context of their school and personal relationships.

Point of View:

The novel is written in the first-person point of view, primarily from the perspective of the main character, Autumn.


The main characters include Autumn and Finny, best friends who navigate the challenges of high school and friendship. The novel features a cast of supporting characters who play significant roles in the protagonists' lives.

2. Synopsis

"If He Had Been with Me" by Laura Nowlin follows the story of two best friends, Autumn and Finny, as they navigate the complexities of high school, friendship, and love. Told from the perspective of Autumn, the novel explores the deep bond between the two friends and the unspoken feelings that linger beneath the surface.

Autumn and Finny have been inseparable since childhood, sharing a close friendship that seems unbreakable. However, as they enter their senior year of high school, they find themselves facing new challenges and changes. Autumn is introspective and contemplative, while Finny is outgoing and charismatic. The dynamics of their friendship are put to the test as they grapple with the expectations of adulthood and the uncertain future that lies ahead.

The title, "If He Had Been with Me," suggests a contemplation of alternate possibilities and what-ifs. As Autumn reflects on their relationship, readers are taken on an emotional journey, exploring themes of self-discovery, love, and the impact of choices on the course of one's life.

The novel delves into the intricacies of teenage emotions and the significance of relationships during a pivotal time in one's life. Laura Nowlin's storytelling captures the poignant moments of adolescence and the bittersweet realization that some things can never be the same. "If He Had Been with Me" is a heartfelt and thought-provoking exploration of friendship, love, and the complexities of growing up.

3. Summary

"If He Had Been with Me" by Laura Nowlin is a poignant and introspective young adult novel that explores the intricacies of friendship, love, and self-discovery during the tumultuous time of adolescence. At the heart of the story are two best friends, Autumn and Finny, who have been inseparable since childhood. The narrative unfolds through the eyes of Autumn as she reflects on their journey, contemplating the unspoken feelings and the potential impact of choices on the trajectory of their lives.

The novel begins with Autumn, a reflective and observant teenager, contemplating the nature of friendships and relationships. She introduces readers to Finny, the charismatic and outgoing friend who has always been by her side. Despite their differences in personalities, their friendship has endured, providing a sense of security and familiarity in the unpredictable landscape of high school.

As the story progresses, the characters find themselves in their senior year, a time marked by transitions and uncertainties. Autumn is at a crossroads, grappling with her identity and the expectations placed upon her by society, family, and herself. Finny, on the other hand, embraces life with enthusiasm and a carefree spirit. The contrast in their personalities becomes more pronounced as they navigate the challenges of adolescence, relationships, and the looming prospect of graduation.

The title, "If He Had Been with Me," serves as a thematic undercurrent throughout the narrative. It introduces a speculative element, prompting readers to consider alternate scenarios and the impact of pivotal moments. This speculative angle becomes more pronounced as Autumn and Finny's lives take unexpected turns, leading to moments of reflection on what might have been.

The core of the novel lies in the exploration of unspoken emotions and the complexities of friendship evolving into something more. Autumn grapples with her feelings for Finny, emotions that have been buried beneath the surface for years. Nowlin delicately navigates the nuances of unrequited love, allowing readers to empathize with Autumn's internal struggles.

The high school setting serves as a backdrop for the characters' growth and self-discovery. Nowlin captures the essence of teenage emotions, portraying the insecurities, hopes, and dreams that define this pivotal stage in life. The exploration of friendship dynamics is nuanced and authentic, delving into the challenges of evolving relationships and the impact of societal expectations.

Throughout the novel, the author weaves a narrative that is both introspective and emotionally resonant. The prose is lyrical and reflective, inviting readers to connect with the characters on a profound level. Autumn's internal monologue provides insight into her thoughts and emotions, creating a narrative intimacy that enhances the reader's engagement with the story.

The relationships portrayed in the novel extend beyond the central friendship, encompassing family dynamics and secondary characters who contribute to the protagonists' personal growth. Themes of acceptance, forgiveness, and understanding permeate the narrative, adding layers of depth to the characters' experiences.

As the story reaches its climax, the speculative element of the narrative comes to the forefront. Autumn confronts pivotal moments in her relationship with Finny, leading to a profound exploration of the choices that shape our lives. The novel invites readers to reflect on the impact of decisions and the interconnectedness of seemingly unrelated events.

The resolution of the story is both poignant and thought-provoking. Without giving away spoilers, it navigates the delicate balance between heartbreak and acceptance. The characters undergo significant growth, and the narrative concludes with a sense of closure that is both satisfying and emotionally resonant.

In summary, "If He Had Been with Me" is a beautifully crafted novel that delves into the complexities of friendship, love, and self-discovery. Laura Nowlin's exploration of teenage emotions and relationships is nuanced and authentic, capturing the essence of adolescence with grace and sensitivity. The speculative element adds a unique dimension to the narrative, prompting readers to reflect on the choices that define our paths. It is a coming-of-age story that resonates on a deep emotional level, leaving a lasting impression on those who immerse themselves in its pages.

4. Analysis (symbols, themes etc)

"If He Had Been with Me" by Laura Nowlin is a nuanced exploration of friendship, love, and self-discovery within the context of adolescence. The novel delves into the complexities of relationships, offering a thoughtful and introspective narrative that engages readers on both an emotional and intellectual level.


Friendship and Love:

  • The novel prominently explores the theme of friendship and the complexities that arise when deeper emotions, such as romantic love, are involved. It delves into the challenges and nuances of navigating these emotions within the context of a close friendship.

Identity and Self-Discovery:

  • Identity and self-discovery are central themes in the narrative. The characters, particularly Autumn, undergo a journey of self-exploration, grappling with questions of who they are, what they want, and how they fit into the world around them.

Choices and Consequences:

  • The speculative element introduced by the title prompts an exploration of the theme of choices and their consequences. The narrative encourages readers to reflect on the pivotal moments that shape the characters' lives and how different decisions could lead to alternate outcomes.


  • The novel is a coming-of-age story that captures the essence of adolescence. It explores the challenges, growth, and self-discovery that occur during the transition from youth to adulthood. Themes of identity, independence, and the inevitability of change are woven throughout the narrative.

Loss and Acceptance:

  • The theme of loss and acceptance is subtly present in the narrative. Characters grapple with the loss of innocence, the shifting dynamics of relationships, and the acceptance of change as they confront the realities of growing up.


The Treehouse:

  • The treehouse serves as a symbolic space of refuge and shared memories for the characters. It represents the sanctuary of their friendship, a place where secrets are shared and a tangible symbol of the enduring bond they've built over the years.

The Photo Album:

  • The photo album symbolizes the preservation of memories. It becomes a poignant symbol of the characters' shared history, allowing them to revisit moments that shaped their friendship. The act of flipping through the pages becomes a means of reflection and nostalgia.

The Prom:

  • The prom is a symbolic event in the novel, representing a traditional milestone in the characters' high school experience. It becomes a backdrop for significant moments, symbolizing the transition from adolescence to adulthood, and highlighting the emotions and expectations associated with such rites of passage.

The Beach:

  • The beach symbolizes a space of contemplation and emotional intensity. Scenes set at the beach often carry symbolic weight, representing the vastness of possibilities, the transient nature of time, and the emotional ebbs and flows experienced by the characters.

The Title - "If He Had Been with Me":

  • The title itself serves as a symbolic exploration of alternate realities and the impact of pivotal moments. It encapsulates the theme of "what if," prompting readers to consider the significance of certain events and the potential for different outcomes.

Character Development:

The strength of the novel lies in its well-crafted characters, particularly the protagonists, Autumn and Finny. Nowlin carefully develops their personalities, allowing readers to connect with their individual struggles, fears, and desires. The characters undergo significant growth throughout the narrative, mirroring the transformative nature of the teenage years. Autumn's internal monologue provides a window into her evolving emotions, creating a relatable and authentic portrayal of adolescent introspection.

  • Autumn: Autumn, the protagonist, serves as the lens through which readers experience the story. She is introspective, thoughtful, and carries a deep well of emotions. Her narrative voice provides insight into the complexities of teenage emotions, self-discovery, and the challenges of growing up. Autumn grapples with her evolving feelings for Finny and undergoes significant personal growth as she navigates the uncertainties of her senior year. Her internal conflicts and vulnerability make her a relatable and empathetic character.

  • Finny: Finny, Autumn's best friend, is a charismatic and carefree individual. His outgoing nature contrasts with Autumn's introspection, creating a dynamic and complementary friendship. Finny's presence is central to the novel, and his impact on Autumn's life sparks the speculative element of the narrative. Finny represents the unpredictability of life and serves as a catalyst for Autumn's self-discovery. The complexities of their friendship and the unspoken emotions between them add layers to Finny's character.

  • Secondary Characters: The novel introduces a cast of secondary characters, including friends, family members, and classmates, each contributing to the protagonists' personal growth. These characters represent different facets of the teenage experience, such as peer dynamics, familial expectations, and societal pressures. Their interactions with Autumn and Finny add depth to the narrative, highlighting the interconnected nature of relationships.

  • Family Members: Autumn's relationship with her family members, especially her sister and parents, adds another layer to her character. The family dynamics contribute to the exploration of identity and the influence of external expectations on individual choices. The portrayal of familial relationships provides context for Autumn's personal journey and the challenges she faces in expressing her true self.

  • Symbolic Significance: The characters themselves serve as symbols within the narrative. Autumn and Finny represent the complexities of friendship and the blurred lines between platonic and romantic feelings. Their shared history, embodied in the treehouse and the photo album, symbolizes the depth of their connection. The title itself, "If He Had Been with Me," symbolically encapsulates the speculative nature of the narrative, inviting readers to contemplate the impact of pivotal moments on the characters' lives.

  • Character Growth: A notable aspect of the novel is the characters' growth throughout the narrative. Autumn undergoes a significant transformation, coming to terms with her emotions and learning to navigate the complexities of relationships. Finny's character also experiences development, and the resolution provides a sense of closure for both protagonists.

Speculative Element:

The inclusion of a speculative element, suggested by the title, adds a layer of complexity to the narrative. The "what if" scenarios prompt readers to reflect on the impact of choices and the interconnectedness of events. This thematic undercurrent enhances the story's depth, encouraging readers to engage with the characters' dilemmas and contemplate the alternate paths that could have unfolded.

Emotional Resonance:

Nowlin's writing style contributes significantly to the emotional resonance of the novel. The prose is lyrical and reflective, capturing the emotional nuances of the characters' experiences. The first-person point of view allows for an intimate connection with Autumn, fostering empathy and understanding. The author's ability to convey the depth of emotions adds a layer of authenticity to the narrative, making it a powerful and evocative reading experience.

Resolution and Closure:

The resolution of the narrative is both satisfying and thought-provoking. Without succumbing to clichés, Nowlin navigates the complexities of relationships and personal growth, providing a conclusion that resonates with authenticity. The novel's conclusion offers a sense of closure while leaving room for readers to reflect on the broader themes presented throughout the story.

5. Review

Laura Nowlin's "If He Had Been with Me" is a poignant and thought-provoking exploration of the complexities of teenage emotions, friendship, and the profound impact of pivotal moments. This novel is highly recommended for readers who appreciate nuanced coming-of-age stories that delve into the intricacies of relationships and self-discovery.

The heart of the narrative revolves around the enduring friendship between Autumn and Finny, two characters whose dynamics evolve as they navigate the challenges of high school and the uncertainties of their senior year. What sets this book apart is its ability to capture the essence of adolescence, portraying the characters' internal struggles and emotional growth with authenticity.

The speculative element introduced by the title, prompting readers to consider alternate possibilities, adds a layer of depth to the narrative. This thematic exploration invites reflection on the significance of choices and the interconnectedness of moments, making it a compelling and intellectually engaging read.

The characters are skillfully crafted, with Autumn serving as a relatable protagonist whose introspective narrative provides a window into the tumultuous world of teenage emotions. Finny's charismatic and carefree personality adds a dynamic element to their friendship, creating a narrative tension that keeps the reader invested in their journey.

This novel is recommended for a broad audience, including young adult readers and those who appreciate literary fiction that explores the human experience. It will resonate with anyone who has navigated the complexities of friendship and love during their formative years. The universal themes of identity, self-discovery, and the inevitable changes that come with growing up make it a relatable and enriching read.

Nowlin's writing style is both evocative and immersive, allowing readers to empathize with the characters' joys, sorrows, and moments of reflection. The symbolism woven throughout the narrative, such as the treehouse and the photo album, adds layers of meaning and enhances the overall reading experience.

In conclusion, "If He Had Been with Me" is worth reading for its beautifully rendered exploration of the human condition. Laura Nowlin's ability to capture the emotional complexities of adolescence, coupled with the novel's philosophical undertones, makes it a compelling and rewarding literary journey. Whether you're a fan of young adult fiction or enjoy stories that delve into the profound aspects of relationships and self-discovery, this novel is a must-read. It leaves a lasting impact, prompting readers to reflect on their own journey through the lens of Autumn and Finny's captivating story.

6. About the Author

About the Author:

Laura Nowlin

Laura Nowlin is an accomplished author known for her heartfelt and introspective explorations of young adult themes. With a keen understanding of the complexities of adolescence, Nowlin weaves narratives that resonate with readers of all ages.

A graduate in English Literature from Dickinson College, Nowlin's passion for storytelling emerged early in her life. Her ability to capture the nuances of human emotions and relationships is reflected in her debut novel, "If He Had Been with Me." This poignant coming-of-age story garnered praise for its authentic portrayal of friendship, love, and self-discovery.

Nowlin's writing style is characterized by its lyrical prose and thoughtful introspection, inviting readers to connect with the characters on a deep emotional level. Her exploration of speculative elements in storytelling adds a unique dimension to her work, prompting readers to contemplate the profound impact of choices and alternate possibilities.

In addition to her writing, Nowlin is actively involved in literary communities, participating in discussions on the transformative power of literature. Her commitment to engaging with readers extends beyond the pages of her books, creating a lasting connection with those who appreciate the depth and authenticity of her storytelling.

As a novelist dedicated to capturing the essence of the human experience, Laura Nowlin continues to contribute to the rich tapestry of contemporary literature. Her work invites readers to reflect on their own journeys and connect with the universal themes of love, friendship, and self-discovery. With each novel, Nowlin reaffirms her position as a storyteller who understands the emotional landscapes of her characters and the readers who embark on their journeys with them.

7. Book Club Questions

"If He Had Been with Me" by Laura Nowlin Book Club Questions Suggestions:

Friendship Dynamics:

  • How would you describe the friendship between Autumn and Finny? How do their personalities complement or contrast each other? How does their friendship evolve throughout the novel?

Unspoken Emotions:

  • The novel explores the theme of unspoken emotions within friendships. Have you ever experienced a similar situation in your own life? How do the characters' unexpressed feelings contribute to the tension and depth of the story?

Speculative Element:

  • The title suggests a "what if" scenario. How did the speculative element of the narrative impact your reading experience? Did it lead you to reflect on pivotal moments in your own life?

Coming-of-Age Themes:

  • In what ways does the novel capture the essence of adolescence and the challenges of growing up? How do the characters navigate issues of identity, self-discovery, and societal expectations?

Symbolism - The Treehouse and Photo Album:

  • Explore the symbolic significance of the treehouse and the photo album in the novel. How do these elements represent the characters' shared history and the depth of their connection?

Choices and Consequences:

  • Consider the choices made by the characters and the consequences that follow. How do these decisions shape the trajectory of their lives? Are there moments you can relate to in your own experiences?

The Title - Alternative Realities:

  • The title, "If He Had Been with Me," introduces a speculative element. How does the title impact your interpretation of the novel? How might the story have unfolded differently if certain choices were made?

Character Growth:

  • Reflect on the personal growth of the main characters, particularly Autumn. How do their experiences throughout the novel contribute to their development? In what ways do they confront and overcome challenges?

Family Dynamics:

  • How are family relationships portrayed in the novel? Consider Autumn's interactions with her family and the influence of familial expectations on her decisions.

Themes of Love and Romance:

  • Discuss the exploration of love and romance in the novel. How are these themes intertwined with the central friendship? How does the author navigate the complexities of these emotions?

Closure and Resolution:

  • What are your thoughts on the resolution of the novel? Did it provide a satisfying sense of closure, or were there aspects you wished were explored further?

Author's Style and Impact:

  • How would you describe Laura Nowlin's writing style? In what ways does her prose contribute to the emotional resonance of the novel? How has the book impacted your perspective on friendship and love?

8. Reading Plan

Week 1:

  • Day 1-2: Read Chapters 1-10 (Approximately 60 pages)

  • Day 3-4: Read Chapters 11-20 (Approximately 60 pages)

  • Day 5-7: Read Chapters 21-30 (Approximately 60 pages)

Week 2:

  • Day 8-9: Read Chapters 31-40 (Approximately 60 pages)

  • Day 10-11: Read Chapters 41-50 (Approximately 60 pages)

  • Day 12-14: Read Chapters 51-60 (Approximately 60 pages)

Week 3:

  • Day 15-16: Read Chapters 61-70 (Approximately 60 pages)

  • Day 17-18: Read Chapters 71-80 (Approximately 60 pages)

  • Day 19-21: Read Chapters 81-End (Approximately 56 pages)

9. Facts & Curiosities

Inspiration for the Title:

  • The title "If He Had Been with Me" immediately sparks curiosity, prompting readers to contemplate alternative scenarios. Titles with speculative elements often engage readers' imaginations before they even open the book.

Music References:

  • Consider exploring any music references within the novel. Sometimes authors incorporate music into their works to enhance the emotional atmosphere. If there are specific songs or artists mentioned, listening to them might provide additional insights into the characters' emotions.

Author's Writing Process:

  • Laura Nowlin, like many authors, likely had a unique writing process for the book. Understanding her approach to crafting characters, developing plotlines, or incorporating symbolic elements can provide insights into the creative journey behind the novel.

Reader Discussions and Theories:

  • Joining book forums or discussion groups can reveal fascinating reader theories and interpretations. People often bring diverse perspectives to the table, sparking intriguing conversations about character motivations, plot twists, and the novel's broader themes.

Book Club Conversations:

  • If you're part of a book club, the discussions generated by the group can lead to interesting revelations. Different readers may resonate with various aspects of the story, and these conversations can deepen your understanding of the novel.

Exploring Similar Themes in Other Works:

  • If you enjoyed the themes of friendship, love, and self-discovery in "If He Had Been with Me," you might find it interesting to explore other books or films that delve into similar themes. Comparing and contrasting different narratives can provide a broader perspective on the subject matter.

Author's Other Works:

  • Investigate other works by Laura Nowlin. Understanding an author's body of work can reveal recurring themes, writing styles, or narrative techniques. If you enjoyed this novel, you might find her other works equally engaging.

Reader Reactions and Reviews:

  • Reading reviews or reactions from other readers can be enlightening. People often share personal connections to the story, discuss favorite scenes, or debate key plot points. This can give you a sense of the book's impact on a diverse audience.

10. FAQ

1. What is the significance of the speculative element introduced by the title?

The speculative element prompts readers to consider alternate scenarios and what-ifs in the characters' lives. The title invites reflection on the impact of pivotal moments and choices, adding a layer of depth to the narrative.

2. How would you describe the writing style of Laura Nowlin in this book?

Laura Nowlin's writing style is lyrical and reflective, capturing the emotional nuances of the characters' experiences. The first-person perspective allows for an intimate connection with the protagonist, Autumn.

3. What themes are explored in "If He Had Been with Me"?

The novel delves into themes of friendship, love, self-discovery, and the coming-of-age experience. It also explores the consequences of choices and the impact of unspoken emotions within relationships.

4. Are there any significant symbols or motifs in the book?

Yes, symbols such as the treehouse and the photo album are used to represent the characters' shared history and the depth of their connection. These elements carry symbolic weight throughout the narrative.

11. Books Related

If you enjoyed "If He Had Been with Me" by Laura Nowlin and are looking for books with similar themes of friendship, love, and coming-of-age, here are some recommendations:

"The Perks of Being a Wallflower" by Stephen Chbosky:

  • This coming-of-age novel follows Charlie as he navigates high school, friendships, and personal challenges. Like Nowlin's work, it explores the emotional complexities of adolescence.

"Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe" by Benjamin Alire Sáenz:

  • A heartfelt story of friendship and self-discovery, this novel revolves around the deepening bond between two boys as they navigate their identities, family dynamics, and the secrets of the universe.

"Simon vs. the Homo Sapiens Agenda" by Becky Albertalli:

  • This novel combines themes of friendship, love, and self-acceptance. Simon, the protagonist, grapples with his identity as a gay teenager while navigating the challenges of high school and relationships.

"To All the Boys I've Loved Before" by Jenny Han:

  • Jenny Han's contemporary novel follows Lara Jean Covey as her life takes a turn when her secret love letters are unexpectedly sent out. The story explores themes of love, family, and self-discovery.

"Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine" by Gail Honeyman:

  • While not a young adult novel, this book delves into themes of loneliness, friendship, and personal growth. Eleanor's journey toward self-discovery is both heartwarming and thought-provoking.

"They Both Die at the End" by Adam Silvera:

  • This novel explores the impact of knowing one's death date and follows two characters who connect on their final day. Themes of friendship, love, and living life to the fullest are central to the narrative.

"One of Us Is Lying" by Karen M. McManus:

  • A contemporary mystery that also touches on themes of friendship and secrets, this novel follows a group of high school students dealing with the aftermath of a classmate's death.

"Everything, Everything" by Nicola Yoon:

  • This novel tells the story of a girl with a rare illness that confines her to her home. When she falls in love with the boy next door, it explores themes of love, risk-taking, and the pursuit of a meaningful life.

"We Were Liars" by E. Lockhart:

  • A suspenseful novel with a strong focus on friendship and family dynamics. The story follows a group of privileged friends as they navigate a tragedy that alters their lives.

"The Fault in Our Stars" by John Green:

  • A poignant love story that deals with themes of illness, friendship, and the search for meaning. John Green's writing resonates with emotional depth and authenticity.


Sign up for our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter for handpicked book recommendations, valuable tips, and honest reviews.

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page